International Families in Valencia: What You Need to Know About Divorce and Custody
Life as an expat in Valencia offers a beautiful blend of cultures, but when a marriage dissolves, that same blend can create a complex legal maze. For an American couple -for example- who have built a life here, a common and painful question arises: If we divorce, can I take our child back to the United States, or must we stay in Spain?
As an international family law attorney, I frequently handle cases where a couple—perhaps originally from New York or California—has lived in Valencia for several years. When disagreements peak, one parent often wishes to return home to their support network in the U.S., while the other chooses to remain in Spain.
To understand how a judge decides these cases, we must look at EU Regulation 2019/1111 (known as Brussels II ter) and the 1996 Hague Convention.
- Jurisdiction: Why a Spanish Judge Decides Your Case
For a U.S. couple that has resided in Valencia for two years, the legal center of gravity has shifted. According to Article 7 of Regulation 2019/1111, jurisdiction for parental responsibility lies with the courts of the Member State where the child has their habitual residence.
If your seven-year-old is enrolled in a local school, speaks the language, and has her social circle here, the Valencia courts are considered the most proximate and best equipped to decide her future. The child’s birth in the U.S. or the parents’ citizenship does not override the reality of her daily life in Spain.
- The Custody Battle: Beyond the Desires of Parents
When a judge in Valencia decides who receives custody, they do not follow the personal preferences of the mother or father. Instead, they apply the Best Interests of the Child standard, governed by the Spanish Civil Code and European jurisprudence. The court examines several critical factors, for example:
- The Primary Caregiver (Continuity of Care): This is often the most decisive factor. The court looks at who has actually been raising the child on a day-to-day basis. Who handles the school runs? Who attends parent-teacher conferences? Who takes the child to the pediatrician at La Fe or a local clinic? If the father has been the primary caregiver while the mother worked long hours, the court will likely favor maintaining that stability to avoid further emotional disruption for the child.
- Availability and Quality Time: The law distinguishes between custody and delegated care. Spanish courts prefer the parent who can provide direct, personal care. If one parent has a flexible schedule or works from home, and the other relies heavily on third-party nannies or boarding schools, the court will prioritize the parent who offers more consistent quality time.
- Stability and Integration: At seven years old, a child has a developed sense of home. The judge will evaluate her roots in Valencia. A move to the U.S. is not seen as a simple move back home for the child, but as a total uprooting from her current environment.
- The Relocation Hurdle: Moving to the U.S.
If one parent wants to move the child to the United States and the other parent objects, this is legally classified as an International Relocation. Under the 1980 Hague Convention on Child Abduction, moving a child across borders without the other parent’s consent or a court order is illegal and can lead to severe legal consequences.
To win a relocation case, the parent wishing to leave must prove that the move is not just a personal preference, but a significant benefit for the child. They must present a Life Project in the U.S., including:
- Confirmed school enrollment.
- A stable home environment and family support.
- A generous visitation plan that ensures the parent remaining in Spain maintains a meaningful relationship with the child (long summers, alternating holidays, and consistent digital contact).
A common question among expats is whether European regulations apply to them if they are not citizens of an EU Member State. The answer is yes. EU Regulation 2019/1111, also known as Brussels II ter, uses habitual residence as the primary factor for determining jurisdiction, rather than nationality. This means that if a family is established in Valencia, the Spanish courts are legally mandated by this European framework to handle divorce and custody proceedings. The law prioritizes the child’s actual center of life over the passports held by the parents, ensuring that legal decisions are made by the court closest to the child’s daily reality.
Call us for a consultation
Sandra Márquez